Where to Eat Near Times Square (That Isn't a Tourist Trap)

Let's be honest: the two-block radius around Times Square is one of the worst places to eat in New York City. The chain restaurants, the theme restaurants, the places where a burger costs $28 and tastes like it was made by committee — it's a dining wasteland designed to separate tourists from their money with maximum efficiency and minimum culinary ambition.

But here's the thing most visitors (and even some locals) don't realize: some of the best food in Manhattan is hiding in plain sight, just a short walk from the neon chaos of 42nd Street. You just need to know which direction to walk.

The Golden Rule: Walk West

This is the single most important piece of dining advice you'll get for Midtown Manhattan: walk west. Every block you move away from Times Square toward the Hudson River, the food gets dramatically better and the prices get noticeably more reasonable. By the time you reach 9th Avenue — a distance of roughly three blocks from the center of Times Square — you've entered an entirely different culinary universe.

The reason is simple economics. Rent on Broadway and 7th Avenue near Times Square is astronomical, which means restaurants there need to maximize revenue per seat with high prices and rapid turnover. They're designed for volume, not quality. On 9th Avenue, rents are lower, which means restaurants can invest more in ingredients and craft, serve more generous portions, and still charge less. The food is better because it can afford to be better.

Hell's Kitchen: Your Dining Destination

Hell's Kitchen stretches roughly from 34th to 59th Street, west of 8th Avenue. Once known as one of Manhattan's rougher neighborhoods, it's been reborn over the past two decades as one of the city's most exciting food destinations. The diversity is staggering: Thai, Ethiopian, Mexican, Italian, Greek, Indian, Japanese — all within a few blocks of each other, most of it excellent, almost none of it touristy.

What makes Hell's Kitchen special isn't just the variety — it's the neighborhood's character. These aren't outposts of national chains or celebrity-chef vanity projects (though a few of those exist too). These are the kinds of restaurants where the owner is often behind the counter, where the menu reflects a genuine culinary point of view, and where regulars know the staff by name.

9th Avenue between 46th and 54th Street is the epicenter — a stretch so dense with good restaurants that locals call it "Restaurant Row West." (The official Restaurant Row on 46th between 8th and 9th is fine, but the real action has moved westward.) Here you'll find everything from tiny ramen counters to full-service izakayas to intimate wine bars.

The Pre-Show Dinner Strategy

If you're seeing a Broadway show (curtain times typically 7 PM for evening performances, 8 PM for some shows), timing your dinner is crucial. Here's the strategy that theater-savvy New Yorkers use:

1. Book for 5:30–6:00 PM. This gives you a relaxed 90 minutes before a 7 PM curtain. You won't feel rushed, and restaurants are less crowded at this hour.
2. Walk to 9th Avenue. The walk from any 9th Avenue restaurant to most Broadway theaters is 8-12 minutes. Factor this into your timeline.
3. Order strategically. Skip the multi-course marathon. Choose an appetizer and an entrée, or a few shared plates. You want to feel satisfied, not stuffed — sitting through a 2.5-hour show on an overfull stomach is nobody's idea of fun.
4. Have one drink, not three. A glass of sake or a beer enhances the evening. Three cocktails before a show makes Act Two a blur.

For Japanese dining specifically, an izakaya is the perfect pre-show format. The sharing-plate model means food arrives quickly and in waves — you're not waiting 25 minutes for a single entrée. Order edamame, a few pieces of sushi, maybe gyoza, and you're perfectly fueled for an evening at the theater.

Post-Show: Where to Eat After Broadway

Here's where Hell's Kitchen truly shines. Most shows end between 9:30 and 10:30 PM — a time when many Midtown restaurants have already flipped their chairs. But on 9th Avenue, the night is just getting started.

This is where the izakaya tradition becomes particularly relevant. At Showa Era, our kitchen runs until 1 AM on weeknights and 2 AM on weekends. When you emerge from a show at 10 PM, buzzing with the energy of live theater and hungry for something real, an izakaya is exactly what the moment calls for. Settle into a table, order a round of drinks, let the small plates arrive in waves, and decompress into the kind of evening that turns a night at the theater into a full experience.

The post-show crowd at Hell's Kitchen restaurants has a particular energy — you're surrounded by people who've just shared the same collective experience of live performance. The conversations are animated, the mood is celebratory, and the food tastes better for it. This is one of the genuine pleasures of theater-district dining that the Times Square chains can never replicate.

How to Spot a Tourist Trap

Before we tell you where to eat, let's make sure you know where not to eat. Here are the telltale signs of a Times Square tourist trap:

• Laminated menus with photos. Quality restaurants use paper or bound menus. Laminated menus with glossy food photos are a major red flag.
• Someone standing outside trying to get you in. Good restaurants don't need to recruit from the sidewalk. If they're working that hard to fill seats, ask yourself why.
• "World Famous" in the name. If it were actually world-famous, it wouldn't need to tell you.
• Prices that seem oddly high for the type of food. $26 for mac and cheese? $18 for a Caesar salad? That's Times Square tax, not quality pricing.
• The menu tries to do everything. Burgers AND sushi AND pasta AND tacos? A restaurant that claims to do everything well does nothing well. Good restaurants have a focused identity.

The Insider's 9th Avenue Guide

Rather than creating an exhaustive list of every restaurant near Times Square (there are entire apps for that), here's the local's framework for how to think about dining in the neighborhood:

For Japanese / izakaya: 9th Avenue between 50th and 53rd is your zone. This stretch has quietly become one of the most interesting corridors for Japanese food in Midtown. Showa Era Izakaya at 767 9th Ave anchors the block with its full izakaya experience — sushi, ramen, sake, small plates — open late enough to serve the post-show crowd with the same quality as the pre-show diners.

For pre-show efficiency: Izakaya-style dining is ideal because the shared-plate format means food arrives quickly. You can be in and out in 60-75 minutes with a full, satisfying meal — or linger for two hours if the show isn't until 8 PM.

For post-show celebration: The best post-show experience isn't a rushed meal — it's a proper decompression. An izakaya's rhythm (drinks first, then small plates, then something substantial) naturally paces an evening that extends organically past midnight.

For the Broadway-and-beyond experience: The smartest theatergoers plan their dining as carefully as they plan their tickets. A great pre-show dinner sets the tone; a great post-show meal extends the magic. When both are on 9th Avenue, the whole evening flows seamlessly between food, theater, and the kind of night that New York does better than anywhere on earth.

Continue Reading

What Makes a Late-Night Izakaya in Hell's Kitchen So Special?

The Best Japanese Comfort Food You Can Get in New York

Seasonal Japanese Dining: What to Eat and When in NYC